Your browser is not supported. We do our best to optimize our websites to the most current web browsers. Please try another browser.
Skip to main content

Should You Rent or Buy? Scott McGillivray Weighs the Pros and Cons

Should You Rent or Buy? Scott McGillivray Weighs the Pros and Cons

Scott McGillivray is a real estate expert and host of HGTV Canada’s Income Property and Moving the McGillivrays.


To buy or not to buy, that is the question. And in today’s market, it isn’t necessarily an easy question to answer. When it comes to investing in real estate, I often recommend getting into the market as soon as possible and finding ways to increase the value of the property. However, that’s not the right answer for everyone. Before deciding whether you’re going to buy or rent a home, consider the pros and cons of each.

Buying: Pros 

  • Buying a house can be a great investment. When you purchase a home, you immediately start building equity.
  • You can renovate to make it exactly what you want. While there can be limitations (particularly in condominiums), if you don’t like something, you can usually change it.
  • You can make value-added improvements. This means more money when you sell and/or the opportunity to refinance and pull money out of the home for other reasons.
  • There are tax credits that can help offset some of the costs. They vary based on several different factors, but they do exist.


Buying: Cons

  • It requires a big down payment; and for a lot of people who are just starting out, coming up with the money can be difficult.
  • It’s a long-term financial commitment. While you will build equity over time, it takes many years to see the benefit.
  • It’s a long-term location commitment. While you can change pretty much everything about a house, you can’t change where it’s situated.
  • You are responsible for all maintenance and repairs – and they’re not free! No landlord is going to show up and shovel the snow or fix the washing machine.

Renting: Pros

  • One of the best things about renting is that you are not tied down to a mortgage, so you can move as often as you want. You can try out new locations until you find the right one.
  • You can likely afford to rent in an area you can’t afford to buy in. If you have kids, this can mean better schools, better transportation and more.
  • You’re not responsible for maintenance or repairs. If something breaks, just call the landlord. No emergency repair fund needed.
  • You can take any other money you have and invest it elsewhere. For many homeowners, there isn’t a lot of extra money left over.

Renting: Cons

  • You’re not building any equity. Once the rent is paid, that money is gone forever.
  • You have no control over rent fluctuations. With mortgages, you can sometimes refinance to make things more manageable, but with rent you don’t have that option.
  • You’ll have limited design and decorating opportunities. When you buy, you can do whatever you want, but with a rental you’ll be limited by what the landlord allows.
  • You could get stuck with a bad landlord. If you have to rely on someone who’s irresponsible, it can be a nightmare.

Related: Renting Versus Buying: When is it Smarter to Rent?

So… Rent or Buy?

There’s one thing I always tell people when they’re trying to decide if they should buy a home or continue to rent: try a practice mortgage. For one year, while you’re renting, put aside the amount you would have to pay as a homeowner (mortgage, property tax, potential repairs, etc.). It will give you a realistic idea of how your lifestyle and budget will be affected. If you find it too tough, don’t buy. If you can manage, go for it. And the bonus of this exercise is that at the end you’ll have some extra cash for your down payment.

As much as I believe in the value of real estate investing, I can’t tell you whether you should rent or buy, because it really comes down to individual lifestyles and goals. If you’re looking for long-term financial gains or stability, you will typically do better with buying. But if you’re in a temporary situation or if you have to take on unrealistic interest rates in order to buy, renting can be the smarter option.

Images Courtesy of Getty Images


Latest News

Viva la Magenta! Pantone's colour of the year is here, and we're tickled pink.
December 6, 2022
Learn how to make the perfect holiday wreath that adds a lovely, cozy touch to your outdoor decor.
December 5, 2022
Filled with colour and whimsy, this retro Calgary home inspired by the 1960s and '70s is right on trend for 2023.
December 5, 2022
These chic and sweet Christmas decorations have caught our eye — and our holiday-loving hearts.
December 4, 2022
Surprise your guests at your holiday party with this festive winter wonderland centrepiece!
December 3, 2022
A serious plant lover like Pamela needs a potting shed as beautiful as her roses.
December 2, 2022
Celebrate the most wonderful time of the year without breaking the bank.
December 2, 2022
Beautiful antiques, simple furnishings, and accessories fill this influencer's cozy, coastal historic New Brunswick home.
December 1, 2022
We're sharing how to get Ellen's luxury look for less.
December 1, 2022
This content is restricted to adults of legal age.
Please enter your birthdate to confirm.
Date of Birth