Sep
08

Question of the Week: Are "Granny Flats" Unsightly or Ideal for Aging Loved Ones?

Being a city dweller, I must admit I learned of the “granny flat” – prefab home/portable/trailer placed on your property, purposed for an aging relative – fairly recently. A friend of a friend is from rural Ontario and her family has a granny flat in which dwells her granny.

Photo via Canadian Portable Structures

Ever since, the granny flat has intrigued me. It touches on the widely shared issue of accommodating your aging parents/relatives. Nursing homes are very expensive and not everyone’s choice for personal reasons, while even fewer people love the idea of cohabiting. So, in comes the granny flat.

For a one-time price of anywhere between $45,000 - $75,000, you can purchase an on-site second dwelling and keep your loved ones close while allowing them their independence.  
But – and there’s a big but – many Canadian townships including Toronto, have strict zoning laws that are not in favour. Plainly put, city planners simply abhor the idea and many aesthetes do too.


Examples via HouseSmart.ca.

There is the question of available space, but if it’s there, why should a granny flat not be a viable option? Looking at these photos they really don’t look that bad… ARE they eyesores, or a favourable, dignified solution for our aging loved ones? Would you put your granny in a granny flat?  Did you?  What do you think of these?

Question of the Week is featured every Monday on Style Sheet and FoodNetwork.ca's Food For Thought

Related:

 

Comments:

I would love to put my parents in a cute little flat in the backyard but it would likely be one of those more modular looking prefab homes... the in-laws on the otherhand can go live in their own daughters backyard.

September 8, 2009 4:02 PM

 

Setting aside  the obvious aesthetic considerations, the simple message here seems to be "lets just put granny in the doghouse and avoid exhorbitant nursery home fees". Sorry.

September 8, 2009 6:00 PM

 

Granny would object to something that ugly. A FlatPak, house or a Kithaus, on the other hand she may go for....

September 8, 2009 9:38 PM

 

I Love the idea, we have been looking at adding on to our home not working out so well.  my mom is still independent but doesn't want to cut her grass anymore and shovel her walk, so all those worries are gone. I love it!!

September 8, 2009 9:40 PM

 

What Cesare doesn't seem to know is that Grannies prefere to be close to relatives than lonely in "exhorbitant nursing home".

September 9, 2009 7:46 AM

 

Well in Vancouver, the zoning allows for lane-access "Coach homes" which look cuter than trailers.  Out in the country the trailers would be fine though.

September 9, 2009 12:51 PM

 

Those are our two options?

September 9, 2009 2:54 PM

 

I would hardly call that a dog house Cesare, but I do think it may be a very convenient option for both sides...

September 9, 2009 3:25 PM

 

Granny flats are a good idea......but....in the given floor plan, is that the furnace between the bedroom & the exits?? How did that get by the safety experts? Would you want the hot water tank in your closet?

Needs more work.

September 13, 2009 2:59 PM

 

There are some beautiful, space-efficient cottages or coach houses that would be beautiful and still give privacy, independence and make it easier for elderly family members.

September 14, 2009 9:44 AM

 

For any granny flat solution whether a modular or a built on site, you will need a large back yard.  A granny flat is no more obstrusive than most garages and at least it will have full exterior finish.

September 14, 2009 12:38 PM

 
Comments for this entry are now closed.

Back to Top