Aug
05

Design Dilemma with Carson Arthur: Ingenious Solution to Backyard Noise

Amazing!  I hadn’t even heard of this (shame on me!). This week we’re back to Outdoor Design Dilemmas with your ever-obliging steward of the outdoors (have I used ‘steward’ yet?) Carson Arthur, landscape designer and host of Green Force.

 

Today, an invaluable tip: how to reduce outdoor noise, organically. 

For a BC family in distress over their marauding neighbours, Carson suggests some interesting outdoor partitions and an ingenious product which won the 2008 Toronto Green Award: The Living Wall.

Before I move onto the advice, I wanted to elaborate on this incredible find. The Living Wall or fence is based on an old technique of weaving willow saplings together to form a natural, green fence and sound barrier. The willow saplings used by company founder Toni Biglieri are robust in nature, perfectly resistant in both extreme heat and cold, and take root in as little as five weeks. At least 90% of the fence frame is recyclable, and most importantly, The Living Wall gives back in the form of CO2 absorption and other pollution filtration. The website even makes a Do-it-yourself guide available. I thought I’d highlight this amazing resource as I myself was not aware of such a choice.

From Marty: "We are out in BC and are hoping to renovate our deck. Our dilemma is our very loud neighbours.  Not only are they loud, but their language in definitely inappropriate and we have young kids.  There is a chain link fence between our properties – what would you suggest to create a noise barrier? We are planning on a large addition and a deck upgrade off the kitchen, and were thinking of a concrete/wall of some type on the neighbour side, with a water feature to buffer the noise.
Any suggestions from your creative team would be much appreciated."

Carson suggests: Hello Marty. That’s a pretty challenging question. The reality is, nothing is going to make the noise go away, or the neighbours for that matter. Here is what I would do providing that you have enough space in the yard:


The first layer of noise protection is a product called Living Wall (above left).  What’s nice about this product is that because it’s considered a shrub, most municipal codes allow you to let it grow vertically as high as you want, providing it doesn’t cause safety issues.  In front of this giant hedge, I would place a lower decorative wall to help define the space a little better.  Try using a low retaining wall which is no higher then 24” [example pictured at right]. That way it doubles as a bench to give you some extra seating.  If you’d like to go with something a little more modern, try a striking parged wall [left] with a circle focal point as the one pictured here. Good luck!

-- Carson

Can anyone else relate?  What was your solution?

Got your own Design Dilemma, outdoor on indoor?  Take a photo, and send it (in jpeg format) along with your question to stylesheet(@)hgtv(.)ca.  (Don’t forget to take out the brackets when typing out email address.)

Previously on Design Dilemma: Cheryl Torrenueva of Restaurant Makeover helps with a Kitchen Reno

Related:

 

Comments:

A water feature of some sort might mask some of the din from the neighbours and create a nice serene atmosphere for Marty's family.  I think the living wall idea is super, does it look better than a row of cedars?  How much trimming does it require?

August 5, 2009 8:44 PM

 

Great ideas.  Water feataure would definitely mask some noise and create a peaceful atmosphere.

(Anyone got suggestions to block our neighbour's smelly cigar smoke that inevitably comes our way when we're eating/entertaining on our deck?)

August 6, 2009 2:32 AM

 

Re: cigar smoke. How about a couple of fans pointed their way........hopefully with enough power to blow tthe odor back where it came from ?

You have my sympathy.

August 6, 2009 4:32 AM

 

Thank you for your wonderful idea for my dilema Carson!  I love them all and we should be starting the deck soon.  Will send pics in once it is completed.  Thank you to all others who have commented, keep the ideas coming!  : )  

August 9, 2009 9:43 AM

 

Anne, nice idea to use fans!  I have to admit one night a few weeks ago I very loudly announced to the kids that they have permission to take their plates indoors and finish their dinners due to the stinky smell.  (the neighbour's wife happened to be outside at the time too).  So far so good as I'm sure the wife heard and perhaps "smartened him up"..

Marty, can't wait to see what you come up with.

August 10, 2009 10:24 PM

 

I live on the Sunshine Coast in BC and being a stager am always looking for interesting ideas to block out unsightly views, the living wall with willow, does that work with our dry summers, willow requires alot of water I thought.

August 14, 2009 1:21 AM

 

Good question about the water requirements, June (funny I just happened to find this page the same day you did, my first day on the site) - the high-as-you-want living wall idea sounds intriguing to me too, for a future home to prevent neighbour problems from the start (Marty's neighbours sound a lot like ours). I think willow roots go very deep though, so perhaps they take care of their own water requirement? I wonder also if the wall can also block heavy smoke from inappropriate backyard burning?

August 14, 2009 7:08 PM

 

Does anyone know WHAT KIND of willows these are or what these willows are called?  The livingwall website has them at $110. for 20 which will only do for 1 meter (40" wide).  There must be a cheaper way to buy them.

Any ideas?

August 15, 2009 1:23 PM

 

Hey Sal,  the willow is pretty standard fare.  If you want a less expensive alternative, try your local florist in October.  They often bring in Willow to be used in planters and urns.  Often these shoots are placed in water and root, perfect for creating your own living wall.  Good Luck - Carson

August 24, 2009 4:45 PM

 
Comments for this entry are now closed.

Back to Top