Jul
12

Question of the Week: Are Faux-finished Walls Tacky/Over?

Do people still do that?  I’m not being facetious – I really am wondering.  

There was a period between the late 80s to mid-to-late 90s that ragging, sponging, “marbling” and wrapping the paint roller in all kinds of household items such as plastic bags, mop heads, socks (ok, I made that up), etc., was all the rage.  I myself had sponged many a wall in mine and my friends’ first apartments, and in fact, spent a whole summer once helping a friend’s mother – a professional artist – transform the white walls of a 26,000 square-foot mansion on Toronto’s ritzy Post Road (yes, that’s thousands) into faux travertine bricks complete with vines.

"Dynamic" Floppy roller, Home Depot Canada

It was quite something, let me tell you; perched on precarious scaffolding, my girlfriend, her mother and I, charted and taped out the brick pattern, sponged the heck out of the wall with three different colours (wielding two sponges simultaneously), sprayed on some white “divots” by running our fingers over the bristles of a nail scrubbing brush and once the tape was removed, added some perspective to the “grout” with semi-translucent artist markers.  

After that summer I never wanted to see another faux-finished wall ever again, but for what it’s worth – even though the family could have afforded to build themselves a real travertine chateau – it looked pretty convincing.

While mine is an extreme example, I have to wonder what ever became of all those earnest efforts to free one’s self from the confines of the plain, gypsum wall.  I’m not a fan of anything that masquerades as something it’s not (veneers, “tile” linoleum, laminate flooring), but I have seen some artful faux finishes such as the ones by my friend’s mother that I would think twice about painting over if I inherited it with a home…

What do you say?  Does/should anyone faux-finish their walls?  Or is it a dying trend having learned our lesson since the questionable styles of the 80s and 90s?  

Question of the Week is featured every Monday on Stylesheet.  

Related:

All things DIY Decor on HGTV.ca

 

Comments:

I did an entire apartment in them 10 years ago but I do think their time has come and gone. Simple and elegant seems to be the way to go these days! -- scotch mommy

July 13, 2009 11:56 AM

 

I think that most faux finishes just end up looking like a dirty, messy wall but I will admit that as a teenager I painted my wall blue and added fluffy white clouds.

July 13, 2009 12:25 PM

 

Gone are the days of using a crumpled plastic bag on a freshly painted wall.  This just screams early 90's!  However, many of the faux-suade wallpapers look very elegant when paired with the proper decor.

July 13, 2009 2:35 PM

 

I think faux-finishings using crumpled bags is of the past, but I have seen marbleizing techniques that can surely deceive.

We're now more into straight clean lines like these :livealindalife.blogspot.com/search?q=paint+                 if we decided that the plain old walls just don't cut it

 

I think faux-finishes still look great if done properly.  I've seen many done with too many different colors and you could actually see the device on the wall in which it was applied with.  Done properly you shouldn't even know what was used to do the finish. Sponges etc.  I do faux finishes professionally and they are beautiful and add great depth to the walls.

-

July 13, 2009 7:39 PM

 

I bought a townhouse that had every single wall, counter and floor covered in a faux finish of some sort or other.  It took me 3 years to get everything back to regular finishes.  What a nightmare the faux finishes looked.   They were definitely tacky and just plain ugly.   Less is more!!!!

July 14, 2009 7:54 AM

 

If the Faux Finish is done well it won't look tacky and ugly, but like everything else, people try to do it themselves and not all of have that forte. Leave it to the experts and everyone will be happier with the results.

July 14, 2009 3:54 PM

 

I agree 105% with Deborah's comment. :)    IF done properly  'faux-finished' painting of any kind can be very esthetic.    A prime example is that  which is frequently used for architectural elements  in movies, the theatre,  etc.  

-Brenda-

July 14, 2009 5:02 PM

 

I totally agree with Deborah.

July 14, 2009 6:54 PM

 

I like faux finishes when you are dealing with older homes and you want to add character and change without the cost of renovation.

If you are working with new gysum walls or walls without problems,,, use your fabrics and furniture to add texture, use your wall to work with color, light and space allusion.

Just my thoughts!

July 15, 2009 8:38 AM

 

Like others, I too agree with Deborah.  I did two of my kids bedrooms a number of years ago and refuse to redo as they still look great.  My son's room is sports themed with Toronto Maple Leaf blue "jeans" walls and red drapes and accessories.  Works well with sports stuff.  My daughters room is pale pink "jeans" done in 4 foot wide panels so it almost looks like wallpaper.  The "seams" have little white "stitches" painted from ceiling to floor.  Most folks ask if I've wallpapered their rooms.  I wouldn't do faux anywhere else.

July 15, 2009 7:03 PM

 

I covered over my faux finished kitchen. It was cute in my older home...looked very bistro. But I got tired of it and wanted a cleaner line, still I left a bit for fun in one area that will remain till I do a major kitchen reno. I used faux finish as feature walls...I am very pleased with the results elsewhere, but the finish is so fine that people would not know whether they were wall paper or some other materials. As accents, it was inexpensive and effective. Anyhow, if you love it...why not?

July 17, 2009 5:33 PM

 

Having lived through too many friends who "did-it-them-selves" and colours that were never close to each other on the colour wheel to be considered even cousins, I would have said the trend was long over. But having seen the clean lines and flat walls for so many years I am starting to warm to the idea of finely finished walls with depth and subtle interest. I don't mean I want to see faux brick, lattice or marble, I would prefer the real thing in these cases. What I would like to see again are walls with subtle variation, movement and texture. I am thinking Venetian plaster, suede, leather or crushed velvet when lighting can play up the effects for the most dramatic results!

July 21, 2009 10:45 PM

 

If done correctly it is o.k., as for myself I am over the faux- sponge look. I had afriend who took a class, and did the leather-look finish and it looks great. So if you learn from a professional that may make the difference in good faux, and faux faux!!

July 29, 2009 1:59 PM

 

Faux finishing is again becoming..........vogue?  Yes, I said vogue.  Faux finishing is NOT sponge painting or swooshing anymore!  Concrete faux and venetian plastering tecniques are all the rage, and very convincing evan to the trained eye.  I do agree with LaRonda and the other commentors that they should be applied correctly, or by a hired professional to achieve the desired affect.  Faux is again vogue!  

September 9, 2009 1:26 AM

 
Comments for this entry are now closed.

Back to Top