Jul
05

Question of the Week: Swimming Pools: Great for 3 Months, Bad for Resale?



Well, for three months in Ontario anyway... (Maybe four months in Vancouver?)  

I've always had mixed feelings about swimming pools.  I grew up in an apartment building with a pool, and no matter how hot it got, I couldn't shake the horrid image of that pool in the winter months (all green and garbage-clogged) to set a toe in it in the summer.

In high school, some of my better-off friends had homes with pools, but even then I thought them largely tasteless-looking and laden with unsightly plastic apparatus which always somehow looked dirty. 

My verdict? To have a pool like we see in the magazines, you need lots of $$$ and a pool person (boy please!) to look after it.  But now that I'm a mom and spend lots of time at home, the lack of a pool sure seems glaring when your child is wilting beside the flaccid sprinkler... (I live downtown, and our water pressure is not so much.) 

A girlfriend of mine who holds the same prejudice against middle-of-the-road residental pools, now lives sandwiched between two homes with pools, and I quote, "I must admit, it's really hard to listen to the good times."

But then there's the larger question of resale.  A widely held opinion in real estate is that swimming pools are bad for resale.  They eat up backyard space, they can be hazardous for young children, they require loads of maintenance and some even see them as the ultimate in anti-green living. 

Now that the heat is on here in Ontario, I'm starting to look longingly at those turtle-printed plastic tubs I swore to deprive my child of, simply for their awfulness.

What do you say? Does a pool entice or discourage you from a property? 

Take a poll!

Related:

 

Comments:

I personally would never buy a house with a pool. I like a yard that I feel the kids can be safe in, then there is the work and expense of the upkeep, and the loss of yard to the swimming hole.

July 6, 2010 12:21 AM

 

We just put in a brand new pool last Fall - and we love what it has done for our household, our family and our lifestyle.  

I wanted the backyard entertaining area that accompanied the renovation, my wife wanted the pool for the kids and so far, we all win.

To each their own, but a beautiful, well built pool in a nicely designed backyard will enhance the value of my house - for the right buyer.  It will limit the number of potential buyers though - so it's a give and take.

July 6, 2010 10:35 AM

 

Testing as I have tried three times to post.   :)

July 6, 2010 10:43 AM

 

We are about to put an inground pool in our yard.  We've always wanted one and we are planning to stay in our home for a long time.  I am not really concerned with the people who don't want a pool.  There will always be people who do.  It will increase the value for those people. We both have good summer holidays and I can't stand the thought of wasting the precious few summer days we have wondering what to do.  My husband says the upkeep will just become a daily task - he already does it with our hot tub.

July 6, 2010 10:57 AM

 

I'm a bit jealous mrskhouse

July 6, 2010 11:07 AM

 

We didn't even look at houses with pools.  Too much work, they eat up too much play space and they cost so much money to maintain.  I'd rather have a hot tub.

July 6, 2010 11:30 AM

 

A pool and a hot tub, now that's living!!!!!

July 6, 2010 11:34 AM

 

I LOVE POOOLS!

July 6, 2010 12:22 PM

 

Okay folks,  fess up, have I been banned from this site?  :)

My comment(S) are not going thru.  :(

July 6, 2010 2:05 PM

 

Hey Brenda, it's probably some weird word that's flagging our sensor.  Try rewording?  Also keep in mind there's a delay between submission and appearance of comments.  

p.s., you'd have to put up some teddy bear borders and carpet your bathroom before we'd ever ban you!  :)

July 6, 2010 2:26 PM

 

I voted YES to your poll.   As a pool owner (past and present) I personally feel there are pros and cons to having one.

PROS --  As far as time, maintenance and cost  they are no more challenging then gardening/landscaping and  .... or owning/renting a cottage.  With 'salt treatment' they are basically chemical free and are less risk for polluted waters. Rigid By-Laws  govern installation &  safety use to a degree unlike  that of waterfront properties.   During hot weather a dip in the pool conserves far more engergy than

air conditioning, fans or taking showers.  Etc....

continued.............

July 6, 2010 2:38 PM

 

cont'd ....      

CONS - If you have children or are a pet owner I feel your property shud accomodate some greenspace.  Lare properties unfortunately mean larger taxes!  Etc.

I cud elaborate more but to 'me' is a pool any different from have a fully equipped kitchen fit for a Chef when you skill is less than a gourmet cook?

FTR I don't even swim but my husband, kids and friends do. :)     -Brenda-    

THANKS ELANA for the posting input and chuckle.  

July 6, 2010 2:43 PM

 

YEH success and YIKES please excuse the above typos.   Frustration will do that to you.   :)     -Brenda-

July 6, 2010 3:02 PM

 

We are currently looking for a new house. We're in our late 50s and have just the two of us (and a dog that doesn't like water) living with us. And I would just love to have a pool.

In the poll I voted "depends upon the pool," but it would have been more accurate to say it depends upon the rest of the yard (and the pool). I don't want an above-ground pool, and I don't want a yard that's just pool. But if I can get them both, along with a house I can live in, I'll be very, very happy!

July 6, 2010 8:06 PM

 

I am more concerned with my resale value, try living next door to constant kids screaming!

July 7, 2010 2:46 PM

 

I would love a pool.  As long as it's fenced off (which most bylaws require) and there is still "left over" yard, I would perceive the pool as a selling feature rather than deterrent.  Especially in this weather!!

July 7, 2010 5:32 PM

 

After building our new home we chose to add an inground pool that we absolutely love! We are lucky enough to have a yard left over that is filled with gardens and yes even some grass....our grandchildren can hardly wait to get here in the summer.

July 14, 2010 10:48 PM

 

I'm all for a pool in this heat - at the end of the day, no kids, our back yard is nicely fenced in, very private, very lush with greenery and plants, gazebo just off the kitchen, just like being at the cottage!

As far as maintenance - when you have a house & yard - you have maintenance either way!!

July 21, 2010 8:13 AM

 
Comments for this entry are now closed.

Back to Top