Jan
21

A Shoestring Makeover Gone Wrong: My Sofa

This is what my sofa looks like today.  I’m pretty happy with it.  But though it sits there as if it always has, it was quite the $$$ journey.

Much of what I purchase, not the least of it furniture, is a compromise.  I can't afford what I want so I always have to settle.  Try as I did however, I simply couldn't forget a certain beautiful, down-filled yet tailored white sofa, by Richard Shapiro (below.)  I searched and I searched, and finally realized that I and my dream sofa came from different sides of the tracks...  

And so, it was makeover time.

I found a ‘70s couch in my local thrift shop that people in my old-school area hoof to the curb on a regular basis. 

  • I paid $150 for it, and although the green one pictured below is not the couch I bought, it might as well be.

The only difference is that my sofa has surprisingly elegant, scooped arms, which is what gave me the final push to pay over $100 for garbage – literally.  Well, ok, it was also the perfect length and proportion for the long wall against which it rests.  The couch is over 8 feet long, but relatively low and not at all bulky.

From the top; Richard Shapiro's Minima sofa; vintage sofa via South Florida blog; my sofa in gray.

Instead of following my gut and just skinning it in white duck cotton (a canvas-like, thick cotton), some friends talked me out of it.  I was pregnant at the time, and having a child, they said, wouldn't go with a white couch.  I don’t know how, but somehow they succeeded – I went with a herringbone wool that I though would look sleek and modern.

Yeah…no.  HORRENDOUS. 

  • The fabric: $150; the work: $450. You can imagine how my stomach dropped when I got that gray, lifeless brick back from the upholsterer’s, wearing a smug price tally of now a whopping $750.  At this point, I could have gone to IKEA.

No matter. I trudge on.  Now I’m stuck with it, and I’m a stubborn lady.  

I decide that this is all my friends’ fault, and morally release myself from the wrong of going ahead and spending money on white slipcovers, in addition to down-filled cushions.  Part of what churned my stomach about the gray incarnation was the ‘new’ foam, totally cheap-looking cushions – soooo bad!

  • White fabric, slip covers, cushions and labour: $800

My white sofa, the very same one you see sitting up top like the elephant in the room, cost an embarrassing $1550!  True story.  

The only thing that calmed my nerves for at least a year after it was all said and done, was that the Richard Shapiro sofa is literally thousands of dollars -- thousands.   So if you look at it that way, I got a deal…right?

Judge away.

Related:

Posted in: , ,

Add to:    Add to Del.icio.us   Digg it!  

 

Comments:

i love your logic...

January 21, 2010 6:08 PM

 

I actually like the herringbone wool... what does that say about me?

January 21, 2010 6:24 PM

 

I like the herringbone too... with the right throw pillows, it could be pretty nice.

January 21, 2010 6:40 PM

 

I wanted the Monterey sofa from Ethan Allen.

Couldn't afford it, so I got the Karlstad from Ikea.

Definitely a compromise, but I still love it.  And I love having a white sofa, even though my friends are just like yours.

January 22, 2010 8:24 AM

 

It's always about the dollars for me too and I've been there and paid for the mistakes too.  Try to comfort yourself with the fact that your first instinct was correct.  The sofa really does look perfect now.  Plus, you can always pull out the guilt card on your friends for steering a pregnant woman down the wrong road.

January 22, 2010 8:37 AM

 

@Nina, IKEA really is the place for a good rip-off sofa.  

@Dawn and mckamp - for real???  Dawn!? You are abandoning me...  I mean, i like the fabric too - I picked it, but the sofa looks so sad like that...no?  

January 22, 2010 10:22 AM

 

I love grey sofas. I do, but I get it. Elana, your home looks gorrrrgeous!  We are currently in the process fo buying all new furniture for our new home.. our choices are about the least baby friendly selections ever. Although we arn't pregnant at the moment... I'm throwing sensibility to the wind for the hard edges and surfaces that I like. Longevity? maybe not.

January 22, 2010 11:18 AM

 

Ph Elana! It's your honesty and humbleness that keep this blog so interesting. I kind of like the herringbone sofa too but then I'm not one for the big white sofa. I've got the big green sofa from IKEA and then some used but beautiful sofas I bought from a friend moving out of the country. They are definately "country", a large check with leather arms and nailhead trim, you would probably roll in your grave.

Good job and glad it worked out in the end!

January 22, 2010 11:19 AM

 

You are a stubborn lady... I think I would have been deterred by the grey sofa, but I think it looks amazing. I've sat on that sofa and it's VERY comfy. It was definitely worth it, I'd say.

January 22, 2010 11:30 AM

 

I bought that green sofa from a garage sale for $18.00 and it lived with me for two years in my university apartment. Safronsky - thanks for reminding me of a true design classic!

January 22, 2010 2:57 PM

 

I agree with you about the gray - not so good, but could have been okay with some nice cushions.  Your couch has nice lines. So it is definitely a keeper.  I think it is actually good that you had to slipcover it with white fabric because now you can wash them!  A definite plus versus reupholstering it in white.  You may want to replace the 3 seat cushions with one piece.  There is just something about a one-piece seat cushion that looks a little cleaner/ sleeker.  Just a thought.

January 22, 2010 6:37 PM

 

By the way, where did you get your coffee table?  I am looking for a brass/glass one. Thanks.

January 22, 2010 6:39 PM

 

I thought your sofa was from Montauk....so I think you did well even with the extra expense of the mistake.

The sofa that looks like yours from Montauk is  called the Julian and starts at $4900!!

I bought a $3300 UpCountry sofa from Goodwill for $75 and with a $500 slipcover it looks great...but how often does that  happen

January 22, 2010 8:47 PM

 

@Karen H., the coffee table is vintage - $100.  The glass needs to be replaced but it has nice 'hoof' feet and a good patina on the frame.  I'm thinking marble?  Or should I stick with glass?

@Super D., I know and lust after the Julian and the Geoffrey from Montauk...Evil, evil, evil purveyors of the dreamiest of sofas.  I love your Goodwill story.  You are after my own heart.  If you look often, that's when you get rewarded with thrift shops.  I go at least a few times a month. It's like therapy...

January 22, 2010 9:23 PM

 

Love your story about your white couch.

Many years ago, we "inherited" a drab green couch from my husband's parents. Even though it was "ugly", it was solidly made, and had down cushions -- something I had never appreciated before. Just like you, we chose to recover it in a white fabric. People thought we were crazy choosing white -- our kids were little and climbing all over it. But I loved the brightness and simplicity of white -- it has a calming effect in a room. From time to time, we got the cushion covers dry-cleaned (now I'd choose a fabric I could wash). The couch looked gorgeous and we only gave it back to my mother-in-law because it was a bit too long for the house we moved to and renovated in 2005.

Good for you in deciding to get the couch just the way you want it. It looks lovely!

Franke

January 24, 2010 11:08 AM

 

Aww!  Thanks...

January 24, 2010 11:59 AM

 

Hi Elana

Could you tell me what type of material would be best for doing a white or natural coloured slip cover?  Looking to purchase a new sofa soon and am curious as to what type of material would be best for a washing machine.  Also, do you know how well an Ikea couch stands up long term? Thanks

January 27, 2010 1:50 AM

 

Hi Pamela,

I used a duck cotton.  It's like a denim and is perfect for slipcovers. I've washed it countless times and it's kept its shape perfectly.  Duck cotton is usually about $6.00 a yard and feels like a denim. For that matter, you can also use white denim.  Re: Ikea, it really depends on what kind of sofa you purchase. The Ektorp - the traditional Builtmore-looking down line is great.  It's one of their highest selling items of all time. But I'm not sure about others.  I know the Ektorp has lots of options for slip covers, but I've no intel on how they stand up to washing.  Good luck!  

January 27, 2010 9:41 PM

 

thank you soooo much for your helpful advice.  You have answered a couple of questions I had on other blogs as well.  

January 27, 2010 10:24 PM

 
Comments for this entry are now closed.

Back to Top